How We Evaluate
Most phone sites repeat a spec sheet. We try to be checkable and to add something a spec sheet cannot: counts across the whole library, gaps shown as gaps, and comparisons that skip thin pairs.
What do we publish, and what do we leave out?
| We publish | We leave out |
|---|---|
| Specs a maker or standards body states, with source and date | Estimates, rumors and values taken from reviews |
| Launch prices with their source | Current prices, deals and discounts |
| Counts and tables computed from our phone files | Lab results, battery tests, camera tests and “best phone” rankings |
| iFixit repairability scores, linked to iFixit | Repair instructions copied from iFixit |
| “Not stated by the maker” where a value is missing | Guesses that fill the gap |
How does a fact reach a page?
- We read the maker’s page, or a standards body’s page, and record the value in the phone’s file.
- We record the source link and the date we read it next to that value.
- When sources disagree, the official maker page decides. If a maker page cannot be read, we may use a clearly labelled secondary source, and the page’s source list says so.
- The build checks every phone file. A spec with no matching source stops the build, so nothing is published unsourced.
- Each phone page shows the date its facts were last verified.
Our editorial policy lists the media and link rules.
How are the data and comparison pages built?
The charger finder, the data pages and the comparison pages are not written by hand. They are generated from the phone files each time the site is built, so their numbers always match the phone pages.
- Charger pages show the port, USB version, wired wattage, wireless standards and in-the-box charger exactly as recorded, and say “Not stated by the maker” for any blank.
- Data pages count the library. For example, they show how many phones state a wired wattage and which facts makers leave out most often.
- Comparison pages put two phones side by side. A row counts as a difference when the two cells are not identical and at least one maker states a value. A pair gets a page only when at least 8 of 13 rows differ.
What do we not do or claim?
- We do not test performance, battery life, charging speed or cameras.
- We do not say one phone is better than another, only what the makers state.
- We do not infer specs from the port, the year or the brand.
- We do not treat the popularity rank as a quality score.
- We do not use maker press images or AI-generated images.
What happens when something is wrong?
Tell us through the contact page with the page address and a link to the maker’s page. We check the claim against the source and fix the phone file, and every page built from it updates on the next build. Each page shows when it was last verified, so treat an old date with care.
See also: about, the phone library and the glossary.