Do I Need a Phone Screen Protector?
Most people buy a protector because a cracked screen is expensive and annoying. This guide sets out what the makers and the glass maker actually claim, when a protector can cause problems, and how to fit one.
What do the makers say about screen protectors?
Read the table before you decide. The makers speak about protectors very differently, and one says nothing at all.
| Source | What it says | What it does not say |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | The oleophobic coating wears over time with normal use; cleaning products and abrasive materials will diminish it and might scratch the iPhone | Nothing on cases or screen protectors on that page |
| Samsung | A case or screen protector may reduce damage; if the screen is already cracked, repair is recommended as soon as possible | That a protector prevents cracks |
| Screen protectors can interfere with the Pixel fingerprint sensor; certified ones are tested for compatibility | That a protector is required | |
| Corning | Gorilla Glass Victus 2 survived drops up to 1 meter onto surfaces replicating concrete in its lab tests | A guarantee against breakage in everyday falls |
Will a protector stop my screen from cracking?
It may reduce damage, according to Samsung, and that is the strongest claim in the sources. Corning’s number is a lab result: a drop tower onto sandpaper surfaces that Corning says simulate concrete and asphalt. It tells you glass can survive a drop, not that your phone will.
Corning also says competing glasses typically failed from 0.5 meter or less in the same kind of test, which is the company’s comparison and not an independent one. If you want a firm answer on scratches, the sources we read give none. Apple notes that Ceramic Shield and glass can show material transfer from denim or pocket contents that resembles a scratch but can usually be removed, so wipe before you worry.
Can a protector break my fingerprint unlock?
On a Pixel, it can. Google says the sensor needs to recalibrate after you apply a protector, so improvement may take a few hours or days, and that even certified protectors can perform worse than no protector. It lists certified protectors for specific models, and says a protector that does not match your phone will not save its information or optimize Fingerprint Unlock.
| Step Google gives | Why |
|---|---|
| Apply the protector before you set up Fingerprint Unlock | Google says to do this if possible |
| Scan the QR code on the packaging after applying and before setup | Google lists this in its setup order for certified protectors |
| If you already set up Fingerprint Unlock, delete your fingerprints and add them again | Google’s advice when the protector goes on after setup |
| Press a flat object such as a card across the screen if a scan fails and no dust or bubbles are visible | Google’s suggested fix before re-enrolling |
| Re-enroll your fingerprint or set up Face Unlock if problems persist | Google’s fallbacks |
We read Google’s page for this; we did not read Samsung’s or Apple’s pages on how protectors affect their sensors, so check your phone maker’s page and the protector’s packaging before you buy.
How do I choose a protector?
Use the sources, not the packaging claims. This checklist comes from them.
| Check | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Is it made for your exact model and size? | Google says a protector that does not match your phone will not optimize Fingerprint Unlock |
| Does it carry the maker’s certification, such as Made for Google? | Google says certified ones are tested for compatibility |
| Can you fit it before setting up fingerprint unlock? | Google’s recommended order |
| Can you fit it without bubbles or dust? | Google says trapped debris can stop the sensor working |
| Do you also want a case? | Samsung groups cases and protectors as things that may reduce damage |
What if the screen is already cracked?
A protector will not fix a crack, and Samsung recommends repairing a cracked screen as soon as possible. See what to do with a cracked phone screen, and screen replacement basics for the maker repair routes and the iFixit guides we have verified. You can also check each phone’s page in the phone library for the glass the maker lists.
Related
What to do with a cracked phone screen, OLED explained, phone accessories, all guides.